Hilda Wade, a Woman with Tenacity of Purpose

July 8, 2014

I never wrote anything about Hilda Wade, did I?

So, obviously I’m pretty into Miss Cayley’s Adventures. So into it that I was kind of terrified of reading anything else by Grant Allen, which is why Hilda Wade has been languishing on my Kindle (and then my other Kindle) for several years. I shouldn’t have worried, though. Hilda Wade is good and bad in almost exactly the same ways as Miss Cayley’s Adventures is good and bad.

It’s narrated by Dr. Hubert Cumberledge, who is to doctor-narrators what many of Carolyn Wells’ protagonists are to lawyer-narrators, except that unlike most Carolyn Wells protagonists, he is capable of seeing women as people. Most of Grant Allen’s characters are capable of seeing women as people. Grant Allen’s female characters command respect.

Anyway, Hilda Wade is a nurse, and she and Dr. Cumberledge work at a hospital with Professor Sebastian, who is a Great Man. That doesn’t necessarily mean he’s a good man, though, and Hilda Wade knows he’s not. It’s pretty clear to the reader early on that Hilda a) does not like Sebastian, b) had some special purpose in coming to work for him, and c) probably wants revenge for something he did to her father. Eventually these things also become clear to Sebastian, and even, eventually, to Dr. Cumberledge.

Dr. Cumberledge is only moderately bright, compared to Professor Sebastian’s genius and Hilda’s superhuman intuition, but he’s pretty likable, mostly because his awe of Hilda turns out to be greater than his awe of Professor Sebastian. Early on, he’s skeptical of her concerns about Sebastian, but she slowly convinces him, and it works because he respects her and listens to her and is willing to see her point of view. And for all that the novel goes way downhill once he is convinced, that’s a really nice thing.

After that, the book gets adventurous and racist and sentimental, but wound to a close entertainingly enough that I never wanted to put it down. Apparently the last chapter was written by Arthur Conan Doyle from Grant Allen’s notes after his death or during his final illness. I have to say, I wasn’t a huge fan of the last chapter, but I don’t know that him not dying would have helped–he has a tendency to fall apart toward the end of a book. That’s the thing about Grant Allen, though: he starts off so strong, and builds up enough good will, that he’s free to make a mess of things later on–it doesn’t really matter that much. I guess Grant Allen’s heroines are better than his books, which doesn’t bother me at all, because the opposite is so much more common.

Lois Cayley is still better than Hilda Wade, though. She’s funnier.



  1. I think I never finished reading Hilda Wade. I know I started it. This may explain why. I’ll try again.

    • Well, if you stop reading before the South Africa section, you miss the worst part, but you also miss the Tibetan part, which is worthwhile.

  2. I went looking for Grant Allen and found “The White Man’s Foot”. Since I went to Hawaii last April, I was hoping for a Anderson like travelogue. Even though the long descriptions weren’t my faves.
    This was not that. I’d describe it as Joe vs the volcano, only not a comedy and not a romance.
    Really different. And so not “politically correct”. I was totally unprepared for how the author handled human sacrifice and cannibalism. It took me back to the Lone Ranger days. I was glad the good guys won, but not too sure the bad guys were so bad that they had to get incinerated. Um, yeah, I guess they did.
    This one has a male POV, with the female being the willing victim.
    No strong females in this one.
    I think I’ll look for Hilda and Cayley. I liked his writing style.

    • Miss Cayley’s Adventures is really the one to go for. It’s funny and the heroine is hyper-competent, and I enjoyed the first few chapters more than most things I’ve read.

      I’m intrigued by the unexpected handling of human sacrifice and cannibalism in the one you’re describing.

      • Just finished Miss Cayley! I wish the whole thing had been a travelogue through her (and Elsie’s) eyes. Agree that the end sort of drags, and for me, that’s because the male lead is way less interesting than the female characters are.

        • Yeah, he’s kind of a nonentity compared to Miss Cayley. But who wouldn’t be? I wish the whole thing was like the first four or five chapters.

          • Oh, man, that would’ve been awesome. Next time I re-read it, I’ll probably stop sometime after Elsie shows up….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: