Precious Bane

April 23, 2011

You may have noticed I haven’t been around much lately. I’ve been pretty busy, and I haven’t been doing much other than working, sleeping and eating. That bit’s over now, but somehow the idea of reading a book is still kind of daunting. I’m working on that.

Mary Webb’s Precious Bane was the last book I managed to finish before I got too busy to read, which was, I guess, a few weeks ago. This is the second time I’ve read it. The first time was during my freshman year of college. It kind of bowled me over then, and it bowls me over even more now.

I feel sort of guilty about liking Precious Bane as much as I do, because my favorite book when I was in my early teens was Cold Comfort Farm, by Stella Gibbons, and when she’s not sneaking in weird futuristic bits about glass pants and videophones, Gibbons is making fun of exactly this kind of earthy rural novel. On the other hand, “earthy” sort of implies that something takes place on earth, and it is my private conviction that Precious Bane does not.

I’ve never been all that into fantasy novels. I read a fair number of them as a teenager, and I liked a lot of them, but I always liked them for the characters or the politics or the swashbuckling. I never got all that excited about magic, or any of the other fantasy elements. Which is not to put down fantasy novels in any way — there were some that I loved then, and some that I still love now. I just never found the fantastical bits to be all that exciting. Precious Bane isn’t a fantasy novel. It takes place in Shropshire. It is, strictly speaking, a historical novel. But it’s also something that I’ve secretly wanted every fantasy novel I’ve ever read to be: fundamentally foreign. This book makes me feel like I’m visiting another universe. It’s pretty cool.

There’s another special thing about Precious Bane, and that is its heroine. Prue Sarn is observant, intelligent, and massively competent — all good things — and also she has something no other heroine I’ve ever come across has had, and that is a harelip. That’s not a great thing to have in rural Shropshire in the early 19th century, because people are pretty superstitious, and the people who don’t know Prue well tend to think she’s a witch, but that’s actually not the worst of her problems. That would be her brother.

Gideon Sarn is hard-working, ambitious, good-looking, and inclined not to pay any attention to the local superstitions — again, all good things. But he’s also completely unable to relate to the people around him. He’s fond of Prue, and he falls in love with their friend Jancis Beguildy, but he is completely unable to comprehend what anyone else is feeling, and that turns out to be something of a fatal flaw. Basically, I guess, he’s a sociopath. And his lack of understanding of peoples’ feelings, and the consequences when he hurts them, causes him to destroy everyone and everything around him.

As the central character in possession of a fatal flaw — and, for that matter, the destruction of everything around him — implies, Precious Bane is pretty tragic: Prue gets a happy ending (heavily foreshadowed from the beginning) but pretty much everyone else dies. And I tend not to like books like that, but this one works for me. It’s not tragedy for tragedy’s sake. All the bad things happen because of decisions the characters make, and none of those decisions are out of keeping with those characters’ previous behavior. And Prue’s narration helps, too, because she’s a genuinely kind and charitable person, and the way she deals with the awful things around her make them seem less awful.

I suppose the narration also makes the book seem less ridiculous, but it can only help so much. Sometimes you will roll your eyes at the characters. Sometimes you will giggle at the things they say — and take completely seriously — but the characters and the writing are both kind of special. Even with all the moments where I was actually embarrassed to be reading it, Precious Bane is kind of worth it.


  1. Welcome back!

    My TBR pile already staggers under the weight of unread and neglected books, both print and e-, and now you’ve convinced me to add this to the list!

    • It really is worth reading, if only because i’s so different. That said, if you read it and think, “Oh, this is just like ____,” I would really like to know what ____ is. (Also, I think my TBR pile has outgrown the concept of a TBR pile.)

      Oh, and: I really do want to have a guest post ready for you by the end of the month, but I don’t know what I’m going to write about. So this is your chance to prompt me with a specific book.

  2. I love Precious Bane, and I’ve read it several times, but I guess in the decade or so between each reading I forget how much of it is tragic. As I said over at SBTB, Prue really earns her happy ending.

    • Yeah, absolutely. And while Gideon’s and Jancis’ and whoever else’s stories are just miserable, Prue’s story is basically uplifting, so that’s what you take away.

  3. I”ve heard so much about this one…and it sounds like I should go ahead and add it to the tbr pile of doom!

    I love Cold Comfort Farm…

    • It really is pretty special.

      And yeah, Cold Comfort Farm is fantastic.

  4. Precious Bane is my favorite book of all time…as in, the one I re-read twice every year. I like your description of Gideon as a sociopath. I had not thought of it that way before–but yes, I think it’s the only term that makes sense. (Mind you, I actually like the guy in a weird way; I suppose Prue’s narration influences that a lot.)

    (I found this by Googling Precious Bane, but I think you’ve got a new fan!)

    • I was just discussing with my brother the fact that I kind of like to describe characters as sociopaths, but most of the time it’s because they’re badly written and don’t really make sense as people, and that’s definitely not the case with Gideon. He works so well as a character. And I agree with you that he’s kind of likeable — he just doesn’t know how to relate to other human beings. Precious Bane really is so good. The more I think about it, the more interesting things I notice about it. It’s definitely not a bad book to reread all the time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: